Mafia Game THREAD
  • 113 posts
  • Page 4 of 8
Tennesseelogman wrote:
i will start the lynch on clubs. everything about him seems to be non-town.
he will likely come back on me
#lynch clubs
feel free to jump in now or pm me for more info or i will post more info here tomorrow
lynch count
clubs - 1
all others - 0 :)
Live long and prosper
Tennesseelogman wrote:
likely 2 mafia, 1 neutral (serial killer), 6 town
if each town has a day and a night ability = then some of the 12 are going to be fairly useless but some are critical. i am town and it would helpful for me to help organize town abilities if i knew where the doc, sheriff, town shooter, investigator, blocker and any other highly useful abilities are. for those of you new to this - i used a tactic similar to this once before when i was mafia and it worked really well - but not this time - - i am town.
the serial killer and possibly one of the mafia likely has a disguise (or mask) to help avoid early detection.
i only have 3 pms to start so it would be helpful if you started one w me
Live long and prosper
2ofclubs wrote:
Still trying to get info to organize your hit list.
You were caught in a PM inconsistency and several know it and have all the facts Ten.
I always smell according players but again I came right with my claim, ability and name. But I was caught in 2 contradictions like you.
I probably won't have to vote to lynch Ten. But I will provide the waxed up wagon.
WRKD4IT
Rockbert wrote:
apologies all. Today was a very busy day and I have not been a good participant. I will pick this up in the morning and get going again.
"A writer is a person for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people."
- Thomas Mann
Tennesseelogman wrote:
i know most would want hard evidence this early but i have none - just noticing some irregularities
his 1st pm to me
2ofclubs said:
04 Sep 2025, 04:24
Hello TLM,
Not much to add from my 1st game thread post. Ok no messing around -
I have a day ability.
I also may earn a night ability if things line up.
I don't have a mask. I have a 1st and last name.
I don't have to be alive to win.
Do you care to share.
the reference to a mask makes me believe he is mafia looking for another mafia (this is before they knew each other) and that he has a disguise that would throw off any investigation by giving a false reading the first time around.
next - clubs has painted himself into a corner by making a claim of being 100% town when he is town. he will give all other kind of assurances of being town when he is not - like 99.99% town or some other wording. he has not given that to me in private yet. granted he may be trying to rid himself of that predictability .
our 1st pm on day 1 was very short and not as warm and fuzzy as usual - gave me red flags
he claims to have no night ability - that is very odd
Live long and prosper
LizardMagpie wrote:
#lynch clubs

I've laid some my cards on the table, and invited others to do the same. I've had I think 4 players tell me their day ability. 1 of those 4 I've been able to prove.

From the PMs I've had it seems very likely to me that either Clubs or Tlm is Mafia. There's a possibility I suppose that both are - but I don't think so. And I certainly don't think they're both Town.

From the content of the messages I've had I think it's much more likely Clubs is Mafia. So my thinking is we vote to lynch Clubs. If it turns out we're wrong and he was Town all along, then the conclusion those left alive would be able to draw is that Tlm is Mafia. But I don't think so - I think it's Clubs.
2ofclubs wrote:
Tennesseelogman
i know most would want hard evidence this early but i have none - just noticing some irregularities
his 1st pm to me
2ofclubs said:
04 Sep 2025, 04:24
Hello TLM,
Not much to add from my 1st game thread post. Ok no messing around -
I have a day ability.
I also may earn a night ability if things line up.
I don't have a mask. I have a 1st and last name.
I don't have to be alive to win.
Do you care to share.
the reference to a mask makes me believe he is mafia looking for another mafia (this is before they knew each other) and that he has a disguise that would throw off any investigation by giving a false reading the first time around.
next - clubs has painted himself into a corner by making a claim of being 100% town when he is town. he will give all other kind of assurances of being town when he is not - like 99.99% town or some other wording. he has not given that to me in private yet. granted he may be trying to rid himself of that predictability .
our 1st pm on day 1 was very short and not as warm and fuzzy as usual - gave me red flags
he claims to have no night ability - that is very odd
I told myself and others I was going let you sing and dance around the gallows pole and defend your up coming mis directs. But I can't resist lol

Mask was as in serial killer reference from story line.
Yes I am trying to shake the 100% tell. I told you that plus nobody but you ever believed that 100% thing.
I said I may earn a night ability (probably game balance for Crys mechanics).
You mention one red flag here are some more.
2. you didn't offer a truce deal.
3. Having stalker in your role PM doesn't line up with town office worker, baker, mechanic, police officer, librarian.... last game when you were mafia your name/role didn't line up as well .
4. D1 you were blocked. You said you wasn't. When called on it by several players. You changed to 'must have been protected. Town would not likely have a day protection ability and wouldn't use it outing themselves 1st phase when kills weren't active. Let alone use it on Ten clubs or hood :P
5. You said working the new guy Jimi would be useful . I take that as pretty scummy.
I have shared more in other PMs with known town. Sorry, I do enjoy having you in games. Lastly I am not telling all like usually- trying not to feed mafia info.
WRKD4IT
2ofclubs wrote:
LizardMagpie
#lynch clubs

I've laid some my cards on the table, and invited others to do the same. I've had I think 4 players tell me their day ability. 1 of those 4 I've been able to prove.

From the PMs I've had it seems very likely to me that either Clubs or Tlm is Mafia. There's a possibility I suppose that both are - but I don't think so. And I certainly don't think they're both Town.

From the content of the messages I've had I think it's much more likely Clubs is Mafia. So my thinking is we vote to lynch Clubs. If it turns out we're wrong and he was Town all along, then the conclusion those left alive would be able to draw is that Tlm is Mafia. But I don't think so - I think it's Clubs.
Here we go again. If I have to be friendly fire, so be it. I can still win when Town faction wins. But seriously you think vs the facts I and others have shared.
WRKD4IT
Rockbert wrote:
Vicious
sorry I'm late... death in the family. 
he was a good dog I loved him alot <3
I am a townie I would like to say that I have not received or sent out a single pm 

Sorry to hear that Vicious.
"A writer is a person for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people."
- Thomas Mann
Rockbert wrote:
We are still in Day 2 correct?
"A writer is a person for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people."
- Thomas Mann
Bluegoetz wrote:
I have a question mostly for the moderator, but since he’s busy I’ll ask the group their thoughts.
How are we handling the pm’s? It says you can create and have up to 3 individual messages during the day. So my question is:
If I make 3 and then someone else creates one with me. Does that count as 4 and I have to say sorry all full here on the honor system? Or is it everyone can make only 3, but can message in those they didn’t make.
Sorry that sounds complicated it hopefully you all get it and have an answer.
Jimi wrote:
Things are still unclear, for now I suspect club more than ten. If club was town then definitely tenn is mafia.
#Lynch Club

“While you were so busy forcing me into a boner, you forgot you were committing one yourself.”

Batman