Salem Witch Trials Mafia GAME THREAD

new guess. Jacob, TLM, and either one of the new players mayday or akua

oh, leaning toward mayday, as i just realize he voted with TLM.

im expecting to see a better investigative role coming from either mayday or akua to help town out. the gossip reporter doesn't quite cut it as investigative.

[b]ABSTAIN[/b] Taking this one slow, folks. No sense rushing things along! I've been traveling this week so catching up on the thread in chunks. Will be back to normal routine come Monday.

To be clear, the only strike against me is that I look too innocent… I’ve seen Ely’s ability as good or bad… will be hard to confirm him town but I trust him reasonably. Still want reveals from Aku and Mayday

3:47 left in Day 2. Do we know the vote tally at this time?

[quote=Mayday123][quote=LizardMagpie]Akuaman and Mayday. So if I was a betting man, at the moment my money would be on Hoodlum and Mayday as Mafia. [b]#Lynch Hoodlum[/b][/quote] I could share my role, but I'm afraid it's too powerful a town role to disclose. Also, as a new player, there's a lot of info for me to process, but I guess I'm js gonna jump onto the bandwagon and [b]#LYNCH HOODLUM[/b]. I hope this is a good decision and we are not wasting precious town abilities that could later save the day in the endgame.[/quote] [b]unlynch jacob[/b]. [b]lynch mayday[/b], he's just bandwagoning, and to save myself bandwagoning back, although jacob is the most sus to me. too powerful a role isn't useful to me if im dying in a lynch. time to reveal, to save yourself, ill switch to akuaman for no reveal

Updated voting so far with a bit over 2hrs left Jacob24 - [b]0[/b] () Hoodlum - [b]3[/b] (Jacob24, LizardMagpie, Mayday123) Mayday123 - [b]3[/b] (elysium5, 2ofclubs, Hoodlum) No Lynch - [b]1[/b] (Tennesseelogman) Abstain - [b]1[/b] (Akuaman23) [i]haven't voted yet[/i]- Rockbert Please correct me if i missed something

i played mafia on the site that has a tourney once a year that we are invited to send a rep to. i played about 4 games there. i did not like it. there, unfounded accusations fly like a hail storm. i was criticized for not wanting to vote somebody off without any proof whatsoever. there were no detectives or other roles. we were required to make at least 50 posts per day. others judged you on babble. most of the posts were babble just to meet the minimum requirement. i would like to hear something from the 2 new players. i am reluctant to vote them off at the first opportunity since i would like to see them play a while longer and maybe come back. if i thought they were mafia due to a mistake, logic, or an investigation = i would vote them immediately. this particular game has played out kind of weirdly and thus far we have more info at this point than usual. hood is just hood and seems to have fallen into his normal play routine whether he is town or mafia so again i am hesitant to vote him off early. we have some decent leads that point to town leaning players and not much pointing to mafia. there seems to be quite a bit of town blocking ability available and most of time we do not have the opportunity to coordinate a defense. i think we should allow 1 player to suggest a use of abilities that do not conflict w each and other follow that plan instead of each doing our own thing and squandering this opportunity.

[quote=Tennesseelogman][b]i played mafia on the site that has a tourney once a year that we are invited to send a rep to. i played about 4 games there. i did not like it. there, unfounded accusations fly like a hail storm. i was criticized for not wanting to vote somebody off without any proof whatsoever. there were no detectives or other roles. we were required to make at least 50 posts per day. others judged you on babble. most of the posts were babble just to meet the minimum requirement.[/b] i would like to hear something from the 2 new players. i am reluctant to vote them off at the first opportunity since i would like to see them play a while longer and maybe come back. if i thought they were mafia due to a mistake, logic, or an investigation = i would vote them immediately. this particular game has played out kind of weirdly and thus far we have more info at this point than usual. hood is just hood and seems to have fallen into his normal play routine whether he is town or mafia so again i am hesitant to vote him off early. we have some decent leads that point to town leaning players and not much pointing to mafia. there seems to be quite a bit of town blocking ability available and most of time we do not have the opportunity to coordinate a defense. i think we should allow 1 player to suggest a use of abilities that do not conflict w each and other follow that plan instead of each doing our own thing and squandering this opportunity.[/quote] If you are talking about Mafia universe, i agree. The championship games i saw dont feel like championship games

[quote=Crywolf]Updated voting so far with a bit over 2hrs left Jacob24 - [b]0[/b] () Hoodlum - [b]3[/b] (Jacob24, LizardMagpie, Mayday123) Mayday123 - [b]3[/b] (elysium5, 2ofclubs, Hoodlum) No Lynch - [b]1[/b] (Tennesseelogman) Abstain - [b]1[/b] (Akuaman23) [i]haven't voted yet[/i]- Rockbert Please correct me if i missed something [/quote] Come on, people. We should not have a tie vote at the moment! This only benefits mafia.

Mayday offline for 9 hours…

Rock, I think we need you here. It is close to the deadline and I'm sure Mafia are prepared for some vote changing shenanigans. Personally, I don't care who you vote for, just make sure it is not a tie. If we mistakenly vote of a Townie, we will have a better idea who isn't based on things said and votes so far. I'm willing to switch my vote at your direction if needed in order to ensure it is not a tie but my peferences at this time in order are: [b]Most Suspect:[/b] 1. MayDay(no reveal and not a good enough reason) 2. Akua(no reveal and just made a tiny post) [b]Less Suspect:[/b] 3. Hood/Jacob(because of the back and forth) [b]Even less Suspect:[/b] 4 Tenn/clubs(know how to manipulate with the best but seem pretty town to me. [b][size=16px]Not Suspect:[/size][/b] [b]At this time I will not vote for Liz or Rock[/b] Whether or not anyone thinks I'm town or not based on my posts and reveal, I am 100% convinced Liz is Doc because he said he was going to use his ability, and that ability was used on me and no one else claimed it wasn't Liz. Liz is 1000 percent town and is the Doc, no question in my mind. Rock's total reveal had too many points/words/phrasing that matched mine perfectly to have any doubts about his role and being town. 99.999999999999999% Rock is town.

I hate to vote off a newbie on the first one, but the dead can apparently participate, so with that I am, unless I see something else,[b] #Lynch Mayday[/b]

I don't have any type of investigation ability. The mayor role may seem powerful to a new player and not be. Also my sheriff role isn't your traditional power role. Rock is the tie breaker in vote and ability (so at this point is the power). Jacob another strike is an open ability to fabricate. You may even have an alternate WC. Jacob Hood and Clubs abilities verified. Clubs role verified. Mayor and old lady not claimed. I speculate Mayday is mayor.. Akua is being guided by veteran mafia and play the new card to stall and gain some mafia ground. Who's role smells the most mafia? [i]Jaco[/i] but it can also be someone else but not both madam and akuaman. Neither will claim[s] old lady[/s] head witch.