cruise ship mafia game thread

[quote=goryh][quote=ajsbus]No my friend, I am not by any means a politician. I am not putting a spin on stuff and talking in codes. I am here to have a good time and drink some RUM and not have people frickin die on the ship. Can you help me with this clubs? The only way for you to help people not die is to walk the plank your self. [/quote] I was going to switch my lynch vote off of you. You defended yourself well, removed your vote against clubs, and clubs convinced my ABS was better vote. Then you undid all of it. To reiterate for everyone: Looking back at post #1 you don't have to be in the same room as someone to kill them (contrary to what I and others assumed). So my killer doesn't have to be KC or clubs. I (wasted) my questions last night to confirm KC didn't kill me (because I thought it had to be KC or clubs). Clubs and I were the same faction, he knew that, and so wouldn't have killed me. I will want clubs dead at some point (unless I go with name win instead of faction win), but for now I am happy to work with him to get the real killers. [b]#Lynch Ajsbus[/b] (didn't change) Happy to change if people have a better option, but no more crying wolf over things that are already settled.[/quote] What do you know about clubs that we dont? Im only chaning my vote if I see some genuine evidence on clubs not doing the killing

[quote=Abs][quote=goryh][quote=ajsbus]No my friend, I am not by any means a politician. I am not putting a spin on stuff and talking in codes. I am here to have a good time and drink some RUM and not have people frickin die on the ship. Can you help me with this clubs? The only way for you to help people not die is to walk the plank your self. [/quote] I was going to switch my lynch vote off of you. You defended yourself well, removed your vote against clubs, and clubs convinced my ABS was better vote. Then you undid all of it. To reiterate for everyone: Looking back at post #1 you don't have to be in the same room as someone to kill them (contrary to what I and others assumed). So my killer doesn't have to be KC or clubs. I (wasted) my questions last night to confirm KC didn't kill me (because I thought it had to be KC or clubs). Clubs and I were the same faction, he knew that, and so wouldn't have killed me. I will want clubs dead at some point (unless I go with name win instead of faction win), but for now I am happy to work with him to get the real killers. [b]#Lynch Ajsbus[/b] (didn't change) Happy to change if people have a better option, but no more crying wolf over things that are already settled.[/quote] What do you know about clubs that we dont? Im only chaning my vote if I see some genuine evidence on clubs not doing the killing [/quote] No genuine evodence can be found cause the kills areanonymous

[quote=Deathless]@ goryh - you are now playing as the old GenE role? unless I’ve mixed it up? If so, the dead gory’s knowledge.should be expunged. [/quote] Valid thought. [quote]Tennesseelogman said: 26 Oct 2026, 16:22 you have knowledge from your previous role - you are welcome to take advantage of that[/quote]

[quote=Abs][quote=goryh][quote=ajsbus]No my friend, I am not by any means a politician. I am not putting a spin on stuff and talking in codes. I am here to have a good time and drink some RUM and not have people frickin die on the ship. Can you help me with this clubs? The only way for you to help people not die is to walk the plank your self. [/quote] I was going to switch my lynch vote off of you. You defended yourself well, removed your vote against clubs, and clubs convinced my ABS was better vote. Then you undid all of it. To reiterate for everyone: Looking back at post #1 you don't have to be in the same room as someone to kill them (contrary to what I and others assumed). So my killer doesn't have to be KC or clubs. I (wasted) my questions last night to confirm KC didn't kill me (because I thought it had to be KC or clubs). Clubs and I were the same faction, he knew that, and so wouldn't have killed me. I will want clubs dead at some point (unless I go with name win instead of faction win), but for now I am happy to work with him to get the real killers. [b]#Lynch Ajsbus[/b] (didn't change) Happy to change if people have a better option, but no more crying wolf over things that are already settled.[/quote] What do you know about clubs that we dont? Im only chaning my vote if I see some genuine evidence on clubs not doing the killing [/quote] I am no longer part of clubs fraction and I am fine with him being killed at some point. But I am confident that he is not responsible for either killing. I learned the first night that clubs and I were the same faction: [quote]Tennesseelogman said: 21 Oct 2026, 12:13 Is 2ofclubs part of my faction? = yes[/quote] Presumably he did as well since he sent me a message telling me we were the same faction and what room to meet in.

@Ten goryh has taken over GenE's role. However his previous knowledge & experience in the old goryh role gives him an unfair advantage. To redress that imbalance, shouldn't all of goryh's pertinent knowledge, messages, experiences in his previous role be now made public to us?

Crywolf?

Brothers there is no need to squabble or kill with no apparent solid evidence to back up our suspicions. Let us all vote [b]No Lnych[/b] and let the dead move to the afterlife in our presence and enjoy the rest of our cruise in peace and reconciliation, as dubious as cruise security and our own nightly observational and daytime peacemaking skills may be. Rastafari! --- [b]No Lnych[/b]

[quote]@Ten goryh has taken over GenE's role. However his previous knowledge & experience in the old goryh role gives him an unfair advantage. To redress that imbalance, shouldn't all of goryh's pertinent knowledge, messages, experiences in his previous role be now made public to us?[/quote] not really - this is by no means a perfect game - i hosted a similar themed game 2 years ago. i made enough changes to it that the players who played 2 years ago would not have a huge advantage over the ones who did not. it should be obvious to all by now that this is mainly a faction war and not a traditional mafia vs town game. when i play, there are often times when some players are targeted early to be killed or lynched based on both past game reputations and current game activities. i do not like (nobody does) being eliminated on day/night 2 and having to sit on the sidelines. therefore, i usually build into my games disincentives for early kills - such as this one = you don't want to take a chance on a random kill because you don't yet know who can help you win. i also don't like being vanilla and others having all the power roles. therefore, each has the option to choose/influence his own abilities/items. i also tried to think of a way to keep dead players involved. kc and npat are both dead (ghost) and have very little chance of re-entering the game - but they can still be somewhat active and can influence the outcome and win if their faction wins. the timing and circumstances surrounding goryh were unique. he should have been dead and stayed dead - but since he didn't - he does have a slight advantage over some (but not all) in regards to information only. and a disadvantage since he lost all of his items in the transference. i will not take that away from him. if you think it's too much of an advantage = kill him again :) or warm up to him and see if he can help you win - your choice. remember - [b]this is a game[/b] - a game of [u]intended deception[/u], it's what you signed up for - have fun. don't hold grudges, play nice, think of a better game and host it, sign up for hoodlum's upcoming game, kill the scum (in this game everyone is a bad guy and a good guy)

[quote=Deathless]Crywolf?[/quote] I would make a bet that if you did this irl, i would have screamed at you for losing my winning streak. of not being mentioned in the forum lol. Does that answer your question? or do you want to call my bluff lol

[b]#No Lynch[/b] Mainly because the drama is too much to let it go to waste. I want them to keep talking.

Looking back at previous posts: Crywolf: post 313 pg21; post 216 pg 15 and pg2 post 23; pg 11 post 161, recall the glass buttons 2C : pg 15post205; pg 14 post 188 Akila: post 193 Abs post 156 Interesting!

[quote=Deathless]@ goryh - you are now playing as the old GenE role? unless I’ve mixed it up? If so, the dead gory’s knowledge.should be expunged. @ 2C - you wrote a list of players you want to kill? - ajs, Abs etc ending w Death? Isn’t that incriminating? You left out CryW - intentionally? @CryW Post 161, pg 21(I think) - did n’t you get my joke? Where are you going to in the night phase please? You are not targeted so being in the same room as you will make me safe;) Lynch votes, suggestions have been made on the basis of lengthy discourses by mainly 2C & ajs. Is that wise? [/quote] Cry was just an oversight - we are not connected. Nothing more about that Voting on = what you know or assume, whats said and not said, vote history/behavior. Etc Your vote have fun. ♧♧

[quote=Akkila][quote]All are continuing with the truce. Then you the Ajs bus to nowhere that no one seams to be riding.[/quote] The truce makes you in my experience more likely to kill. Every time I have played a facttion war with you you have made a truce you have killed the one you had a truce with. [quote]Tennesseelogman said: 27 Oct 2026, 21:10 you have been sent a secret message as follows Akkila isn’t your faction. Truce [/quote] so you are saying that I am not your faction you want to kill me and you have 2 daggers that doesnt leave me with many options [b]#lynch clubs[/b][/quote] No glove = protection Abs ajs kc notor goryh blue cry death zen GenE are also not my faction. My current play is not killing but sharing info to survive the walking dead phase. Vote against play not player.

[quote=Deathless]@Ten goryh has taken over GenE's role. However his previous knowledge & experience in the old goryh role gives him an unfair advantage. To redress that imbalance, shouldn't all of goryh's pertinent knowledge, messages, experiences in his previous role be now made public to us?[/quote] It has if read messages carefully.

Lynch talk aside for just a second-what are we doing tonight? We can’t ignore the ghost factor. I have not been able to be in a room with clubs, death, akkila, zen or gory (and I don’t mind talking to the rest again) One of you might maybe be in my faction, a few of you are for sure in my name category. This is gonna be a survival last man standing type game so alliances would help. Got a few things to offer if anyone is open to listening tonight. Just tell me where (if I’m alive)