Salem Witch Trials Mafia GAME THREAD

Calling you out on babble is never smelly clubs. However, you are not top of my list of suspects for magical behavior. I imagine there are some private PMs going on right now, some with mafia, hopefully some without. Those in these PMs need to unearth as much truth as possible.

[quote=2ofclubs][quote=Jacob24]How did you know to ask about witches to begin with?[/quote] As Part of TOWN, I want to learn what we are up against. Then I disclosed to everybody of their power. So to be clear mafia won't risk keeping me around and I will need protection N2. Both Ely and Jacob are putting smell on me. Making them selves smelly. I am not worried about friendlies because Town folk knows I am part of town. My town play change is only that I haven't shared all I discovered or speculate. [/quote] [quote]4. He will still talk, if he is a witch. Witches can communicate with their minds and do not get affected by a simple xxxxx [/quote] Do you claim a silencing ability? One that only works on town, not mafia?

if you have a private messaging ability = please include me - that's where i love to work things out

I am not sure if there are any town PMs going right now, but I hope you will include me. It would be to our (town) benefit.

Aren't PMs not allowed as mentioned in the OP?

Sometimes, certain town members will have the ability to request a group PM from the moderator.

[quote=Jacob24][quote=2ofclubs][quote=Jacob24]How did you know to ask about witches to begin with?[/quote] As Part of TOWN, I want to learn what we are up against. Then I disclosed to everybody of their power. So to be clear mafia won't risk keeping me around and I will need protection N2. Both Ely and Jacob are putting smell on me. Making them selves smelly. I am not worried about friendlies because Town folk knows I am part of town. My town play change is only that I haven't shared all I discovered or speculate. [/quote] [quote]4. He will still talk, if he is a witch. Witches can communicate with their minds and do not get affected by a simple xxxxx [/quote] Do you claim a silencing ability? One that only works on town, not mafia? [/quote] YES, my [u]SIMPLE[/u] ability as Mod said could be looked at as silencing THAT DOESNT WORK ON WITCHES. I am not going to share how bogus of town ability it is or the words I had with Mod who is always right on it. My only PM is with the Mod. I am [b]part[/b] of town [i]not[/i] a visitor or witch/warlock. My WC with edits to prevent witch forgery. You win when all witches are eliminated. You don’t have to be alive. My role: You're the xxx of Town Town you can see what the edits are. Witches cant. Now you can see other clues in early alledged babble.

clubs - if you can silence townies = then that would be an investigative ability that you could share here. if for instance you request to silence someone and that player can still talk = then you would know that your target is a witch. correct?

clubs is probably town, which makes me sad because mafia will not target him yet which means I will likely be the first to die:(

I think no open PM's with others gives mafia a huge advantage. Some one on ones might help a little but we(town) can not coordinate fast enough behind the scenes like that. We are going to be picked off one after another before we can figure out what is going on. I have a possible solution: Everyone disclose your roles right here in it's entirety. I will even go first if others agree. Mafia will not agree to this as we will have the numbers on our side to win after that.

[quote=elysium5]I think no open PM's with others gives mafia a huge advantage. Some one on ones might help a little but we(town) can not coordinate fast enough behind the scenes like that. We are going to be picked off one after another before we can figure out what is going on. I have a possible solution: Everyone disclose your roles right here in it's entirety. I will even go first if others agree. Mafia will not agree to this as we will have the numbers on our side to win after that.[/quote] That is an interesting suggestion. The only problem is, what if the mafia or some mafia have a win clause that involves killing a specific person? If we all reveal then that person is dead for sure in the night phase. game over.

[quote=Rockbert][quote=elysium5]I think no open PM's with others gives mafia a huge advantage. Some one on ones might help a little but we(town) can not coordinate fast enough behind the scenes like that. We are going to be picked off one after another before we can figure out what is going on. I have a possible solution: Everyone disclose your roles right here in it's entirety. I will even go first if others agree. Mafia will not agree to this as we will have the numbers on our side to win after that.[/quote] That is an interesting suggestion. The only problem is, [b][size=16px]what if the mafia or some mafia have a win clause that involves killing a specific person?[/size][/b] If we all reveal then that person is dead for sure in the night phase. game over. [/quote] Cry said he would run a simpler game, for the new people. That sounds like a complicated win clause that I have rarely seen. Not really enough players in this game to have any neutrals, either. I'll take the odds that there is no such special 'kill one player to win' win clause here.

I’m in honestly,

Only worry here is mafia could ignore and just say they were inactive but that would point us in the right direction

[quote=Jacob24]Only worry here is mafia could ignore and just say they were inactive but that would point us in the right direction[/quote] Mafia will not like this idea at all and will likely try and convince us not to do it.;) Some players could bring up some valid points against it but most arguments against it will be flawed. This is an easily solvable math problem right now if enough of us agree to do it.